Intellectual Property Law Myth- Busters For Non-IP Lawyers
TRADEMARKS:
Myth #1: Trademarking is a luxury reserved for big and rich companies.
Myth #2: Common words and phrases cannot be registered as trademarks.
Myth #3: A trademark registration grants ownership of that word for "everything."
Myth #4: The formation of a company (corporation or LLC) proves that a name is available and protected.
Myth #5: A registered business name with a State or a registered fictitious name offers the same legal protection as a registered mark.
Myth #6: A mark Registration granted by USPTO is enforceable globally.
Myth #7: Once a trademark is registered, it remains registered ad infinitum.
Myth# 8: A proper trademark search can be completed quickly online by amateurs.
Myth #9: One should wait until one's business grows before applying for a mark.
Myth #10: If one is not currently using a mark, one should not yet file an Appln.
Myth #11: As soon as an application is filed, one can lawfully use the® symbol.
Myth #12: One does not need to monitor one's mark because USPTO will not allow anyone else to register any similar mark(s).
COPYRIGHTS:
Myth #1: A so-called "Poor Man's" copyright will protect an original creative work.
Myth #2: If one does not enforce one's copyright, one can lose it.
Myth #3: If one "innocently" copies a work, one does not need any permissions.
Myth #4: If one is planning to give credit to the author who created a work that is being copied, one does not require any permission.
Myth# 5: If one is planning to use only a small amount of a protected work (i.e., a "sampling"), then, one does not need any permissions.
Myth #6: Where the author of a work lives and works in, e.g., France, the work is not protected by copyright in the United States.
Myth #7: If one plans to use another's copyrighted work only for non-profit or educational use, they do not require any permissions.
Myth #8: If one purchases a book, record, or other work that one plans to copy, that person already has permission to use the work they have bought.
Myth #9: If the work one seeks to copy does not show a copyright notice, it is, therefore, not protected by copyright and free to use.
Myth# 10: If one plans to alter a work, one need not seek any permissions.
Myth #11: If one does not charge for the copy, then, it is not an infringement of anyone's copyright.
Myth #12: Any material which one may obtain from the Internet already is in the public domain and, thus, no permissions are required.
PATENTS:
Myth #1: If you have an idea, you can patent it to prevent its theft.
Myth #2: Anyone can get a patent for anything. (Inventions must be new, useful, and non-obvious, and something that can be made or used.)
Myth #3: A patent affords one the guarantee to produce and sell a product.
Myth #4: One needs a working prototype before they can even file for a patent.
Myth #5: Proper searches for patentability/novelty can be conducted by anyone.
Myth #6: Patents remain valid forever. (U.S. patents last a maximum of 20 years, depending on the type of patent applied.)
Myth #7: A U.S. patent protects one's invention worldwide.
Myth #8: A patent has value only if one possesses the budget to sue infringers.
Myth #9: Software is not patentable.
Myth #10: One cannot infringe a patent if you did not copy another's product.
Myth #11: A patent gives one a monopoly on an invention. (A patent gives one the right to exclude others from making, using, and selling the invention.)
Myth #12: A patent is only worth it if one sues all infringers. (It is up to the patent holder to enforce one's patent rights (they can sue in federal court).)
TRADE SECRETS:
Myth# 1: All confidential information is a trade secret. (Trade secrets can cover things like recipes, formulas, customer lists, software, data, compilations, equations, and unpatented inventions.)
Myth# 2: All trade secrets are protected automatically.
Myth# 3: Trade secret protection lasts forever.
Myth# 4: Trade secrets are only protected by State law. (Trade secrets can be protected under both federal (i.e., DTSA) and the law of various states.)
Myth# 5: Trade secrets require formal registration.
Myth# 6: Trade secrets cannot be destroyed by reverse engineering.
Myth# 7: Trade secrets cannot be terminated by changed conditions.
Myth# 8:· Trade secrets cannot be used to hide potentially harmful or objectionable substances.
Myth #9: Trade secrets can include only technical information.
Myth #10: Trade secrets can include only commercial information.
Myth #11: The owner need not take any steps to protect a trade secret. (Prophylactic measures include: NDAs; NCAs, IT security infrastructure, and limited accessibility.)
Myth# 12: The use of a trade secret always means that misappropriation has occurred. (Research and development; reverse engineering; market analysis).
EXAMPLES OF FAMOUS TRADE SECRETS:
- The Google® Search Algorithm Kentucky Fried Chicken® Coca-Cola®
- Lena Blackburn's Baseball Rubbing Mud® New York Times Bestseller List Listerine®
- WD-40®
- Twinkies®
- Krispy Kreme Doughnuts®
- McDonald's Big Mac Special Sauce
Do you want more information?
Ira Cohen is the Founder and Principal of Ira Cohen, P.A. Ira earned his first law degree (J.D.) in 1981 and a second law degree (LL.M.) in 1985. He is a member of the Florida and New York Bars and has been practicing law for over 43 years. He is rated AV Pre-Eminent by Martindale Hubbell. Ira is a Chair Emeritus of the Intellectual Property Law Section ("IPLS") of the Federal Bar Association ("FBA") and has lectured on IP subjects many times.